• Latest
  • Trending
  • All
LAW STUDENTS AND PRIDE: AN INSEPARABLE DUO?_Ismail Khadijat Moromoke

PAYMENT OF SEVERANCE ALLOWANCES AND PENSIONS TO POLITICAL OFFICERS OR APPOINTEES: A CRITIQUE OF THE CASE OF GOVERNOR OF KOGI STATE AND 3 ORS v NUHU AHMED AND 5 ORS (2019)3 AAQR 1__ Ismail Khadijat Moromoke

‘We have recovered reasonable amount’ – EFCC gives update on N1.3trn CBEX crypto fraud

‘We have recovered reasonable amount’ – EFCC gives update on N1.3trn CBEX crypto fraud

Daura v U.B.N PLC: Landmark Supreme Court Decision on ‘Estate and Debt’ Responsibilities after Death

Daura v U.B.N PLC: Landmark Supreme Court Decision on ‘Estate and Debt’ Responsibilities after Death

PROHIBITION OF RIBĀ (INTEREST-BASED TRANSACTIONS) IN ISLAMIC FINANCE: CONCEPT AND SIGNIFICANCE

PROHIBITION OF RIBĀ (INTEREST-BASED TRANSACTIONS) IN ISLAMIC FINANCE: CONCEPT AND SIGNIFICANCE

Hajj 2025: Saudi Arabia deports Sheikh Gumi back to Nigeria

Hajj 2025: Saudi Arabia deports Sheikh Gumi back to Nigeria

JUST IN: Wike seals PDP National Secretariat in Abuja

JUST IN: Wike seals PDP National Secretariat in Abuja

JAMB Announces Date to release UTME Result for resit Candidates

99% Scores Below 200 in Resit UTME – JAMB

2023: Yoruba Elders Decide On Tinubu’s Presidency Ambition

Breaking: APC Governors endorse Tinubu as 2027 Sole Presidential Candidate

Peter Obi attends Pope’s inauguration in Rome to beg Tinubu over Fidelity Bank’s N225bn Debt Crisis – Report

Peter Obi debunk meeting Tinubu in Rome over alleged N225bn Fidelity Bank debt

FULL LIST: Dangote Refinery slashes Petrol Prices across Nigeria

FULL LIST: Dangote Refinery slashes Petrol Prices across Nigeria

Court stops Senate disciplinary action against Natasha Akpoti

Akpabio, Yahaya Bello to testify as Nigerian Govt files Criminal Charges Against Natasha

Canada, France, UK Impose Sanctions on Israel over Gaza war

Canada, France, UK Impose Sanctions on Israel over Gaza war

Peter Obi attends Pope’s inauguration in Rome to beg Tinubu over Fidelity Bank’s N225bn Debt Crisis – Report

Peter Obi attends Pope’s inauguration in Rome to beg Tinubu over Fidelity Bank’s N225bn Debt Crisis – Report

  • About Us
  • Advertise with Us
  • Editorial Policy
Sunday, June 1, 2025
  • Login
iDeemlawful
  • Home
  • News
  • Featured
  • Politics
  • Life Style
  • Advertise with Us
  • Opinion
  • Campus
No Result
View All Result
iDeemlawful
No Result
View All Result
No Result
View All Result
iDeemlawful
  • Home
  • News
  • Featured
  • Politics
  • Commentary
  • Editorial
  • Campus
Home Featured

PAYMENT OF SEVERANCE ALLOWANCES AND PENSIONS TO POLITICAL OFFICERS OR APPOINTEES: A CRITIQUE OF THE CASE OF GOVERNOR OF KOGI STATE AND 3 ORS v NUHU AHMED AND 5 ORS (2019)3 AAQR 1__ Ismail Khadijat Moromoke

by iDeemlawful
December 28, 2021
A A
LAW STUDENTS AND PRIDE: AN INSEPARABLE DUO?_Ismail Khadijat Moromoke
FacebookTwitterWhatsapp

1.0 Introduction

Political office holders had never dreamt that a time bomb would explode against them. The judgment of the penultimate court according to hierarchy of courts in Nigeria released the unexpected in 2019 and it was received with mixed feelings. Everyone was surprised to know if the court of appeal as laid down a new principle of law. It is expedient to critically evaluate and analyze the court of appeal judgment in this instant case in line with the justifiability of the payment of severance allowances and pensions to public office holders ending with some key recommendations.

2.0 Background of the Fact of the Case

RelatedPosts

Trump 2.0: everything, everywhere, all at once

THE DOCTRINE OF SEPARABILITY IN ARBITRATION

Sexually transmitted Diseases and the Law: Can victims in Nigeria seek Justice? by Lanase Usman

MEDIATOR ACTING AS ARBITRATOR: UNDERSTANDING SECTION 79 OF THE ARBITRATION AND MEDIATION ACT, 2023

The appelants in this instant case formerly the defendants was not satisfied with the judgment of R.B. Hanstrup J on 31st October, 2017 at the lower court- National Industrial Court held at Abuja which was in favour of the claimants now the respondents that they are entitled to severance allowances and pensions. Aggrieved, the appellants filed a notice of appeal without the leave of the court since the grounds of appeal are not bothering on fundamental rights as contained in section 243(2) and (3) of the 1999 Constitution of Federal Republic of Nigeria as altered and the appeal is of right. Both parties filed their respective briefs of arguments upon two grounds wherein the appellant raised two issues while the respondents raised one only. Justice Emmanuel Akomaye Again(JCA) who delivered the judgment on the case made an obiter which goes into the root of the appeal which should have quashed the case but it was heard on merit without the court having jurisdiction. This has led to injustice to law, the court and the parties involved.

3.0 Appraisal of the appeal judgment

Regardless of the errors, the judgement of the court of appeal is applaudable. It laid down some principles of law and one of which is that originating summons can be used in cases where the substantial disputes of facts can be resolved on the affidavits and accompanying exhibits without the need to recognize to oral evidence to resolve them. Also, it reinstates the provisions of section 131(1) and (2) of the Evidence Act 2011 on burden of proof in civil matters.

The court of appeal was able to reversed the ruling of the trial court when it held that “since the claimant’s evidence failed to establish their case, the trial court should have dismissed the claimant’s case, instead of resorting to calling in aid, general, terse and speculative denials of the claimant’s case in the defendant’s counter affidavit, characterised them as substantial dispute of facts and on that basis give the claimants another opportunity to represent their case by way pleadings, after a full hearing of their case in merit”. This overruling judgement couldn’t be reach if the justices of the court of appeal where not embodiments of law.

4.0 Analysis and Critique of the Court Decision

4.1 Law is Moral: How sound? In delivering the judgement, the learned Justice Emmanuel, JCA held that the payment of severance allowances to the respondents after their tenure in their respective public offices is morally wrong. The court went further to hold that “the fact that the right (to severance allowances and pensions) is provided in the constitution and thereby made a constitutional right, does not make it morally right.

The questions now are; is the law a moral norm? Has morality taken the position of law? Is law not going to be applicable if it is not in conformity with people’s moral behaviors which are subjective? The penultimate court held to the effect that the payment of severance allowances and pensions to public office holders/appointees is legally right but morally wrong.

This is so glaring that everyone sees the court as court of moral not of law! Morality and law are two different concepts that are different from each other. Though morals should flow from the law, the law should remain supreme over and above morality. It is on this flowery that the court of appeal ruled against the respondents. It is so clear that the judgement can not stand the test of time definitely!

4.2 Jurisdiction: The Life Wire Aside from the fact that the judgement was laid down on a watery stand, the court itself proclaimed that it doesn’t have jurisdiction to hear the suit. Although, the issue of jurisdiction was raised suo motu by the court by the way, it goes into the root of the court to hear and determine this instant case. In fact, the court affirmed when it held inter alia that “as it is, this appeal is incompetent and this court lacks jurisdiction to entertain it”. By going ahead to hear the matter on merit, everything including the judgement delivered is deemed to be an exercise in futility and will be marooned in the miasma of nullity.

Even, Obaseki, JSC(as he then was) propounded in OLOHA v AKEREJA(1988)3 NWLR (PT. 84) 508, (1988)7 S.C (PT.1) that “…there is no justice in exercising jurisdiction where there is none. It is injustice to the law, to the court and to parties so to do”. Since the court does not have jurisdiction to determine this instant case in the first instance, severance allowances and pensions to public office holders/appointees should subsist.

5.0 Conclusion and Recommendations

The court of appeal judgement in this case is clothed with application of legal principles and depicts clear and sound application of law. However, the law is settled that issue of jurisdiction is very fundamental and without it, the whole proceedings of the court will be wasted efforts. The ground on which the court held that the respondents are not entitled to severance allowances and pensions is unknown to law and it may be reversed on appeal to supreme court.

It is only the justices of the supreme court that are regarded as infallible since they are final. On this, the following recommendations will enhance the justifiability of the payment of severance allowances and pensions to public office holders in Nigeria and it include:

1. Until the constitution is amended, the issue of severance allowances and pensions to public office holders remains justified; and

2. An Act of the national assembly should be enacted to facilitate the regulation of severance allowances.

Ismail Khadijat Moromoke A 200 level common and Islamic law student University of Ilorin, Ilorin, Nigeria https://www.linkedin.com/in/khadijat-moromoke-8a72a7213 and reachable via moromokekhadijat@gmail.com and 07014015871

Tags: GPS GadgetIsmail Khadijat Moromoke
Previous Post

MSSN Founding Father, Hussein Akande is dead [PHOTO]

Next Post

22 Nigerian Movers and Shakers in 2022

iDeemlawful

iDeemlawful

Related Posts

Hajj 2025: Saudi Arabia deports Sheikh Gumi back to Nigeria
Featured

Hajj 2025: Saudi Arabia deports Sheikh Gumi back to Nigeria

Court stops Senate disciplinary action against Natasha Akpoti
Featured

Akpabio, Yahaya Bello to testify as Nigerian Govt files Criminal Charges Against Natasha

Peter Obi attends Pope’s inauguration in Rome to beg Tinubu over Fidelity Bank’s N225bn Debt Crisis – Report
Featured

Peter Obi attends Pope’s inauguration in Rome to beg Tinubu over Fidelity Bank’s N225bn Debt Crisis – Report

Nigerian Senate denies viral kiss video says not one of Them
Featured

How National Assembly Illegally inserts projects worth N6.93trn into 2025 budget – Report

JUST-IN: Social Activist VeryDarkMan Arrested by EFCC
Breaking News

EFCC releases VeryDarkMan on Bail

Catholic Bishops Reply Trump Over AI-Generated Pope Image
Featured

Catholic Bishops Reply Trump Over AI-Generated Pope Image

Nigerian Government Announces Public Holidays For Easter
Breaking News

Nigerian Government Announces Public Holidays For Easter

Biafra War: Ndigbo demands ₦10,000,000,000,000 in Damages from Tinubu after IBB’s Revelations
Breaking News

Presidency Reacts to US Court order on Release of Tinubu’s Past Records

Tinubu, AGF dragged to Court over N167b Contractors Fraud
Breaking News

US Court orders FBI, Anti-drug Agencies to Release Tinubu’s Record

[Insider] Power Play at OAU: New PRO-CHANCELLOR Bullying Tactics
Campus News

OAU Student Electrocuted while Retrieving Football

Load More

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

iDeemlawful

Copyright © 2019–2025 Deemlawful Media

  • About Us
  • Advertise with Us
  • Editorial Policy

Connect With Us

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • News
  • Featured
  • Politics
  • Life Style
  • Advertise with Us
  • Opinion
  • Campus

Copyright © 2019–2025 Deemlawful Media

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In