• Latest
  • Trending
  • All
CAUSATION AND CRIMINAL LIABILITY IN NIGERIA; THE POSITION OF THE LAW

CAUSATION AND CRIMINAL LIABILITY IN NIGERIA; THE POSITION OF THE LAW

FG declares free C-Section for Nigerian Women

Drama as 18-Year-old Apprentice impregnates Master’s Daughter, 9 Others in Anambra

JUST IN: VeryDarkMan released from EFCC custody

JUST IN: VeryDarkMan released from EFCC custody

Nigeria Pays Back all N2.59trn IMF Debt

Nigeria Pays Back all N2.59trn IMF Debt

JUST-IN: Social Activist VeryDarkMan Arrested by EFCC

VeryDarkMan’s lawyer expresses frustration over Bail Difficulties

Nnamdi Kanu’s Sister-in-law barred from Court for Livestreaming Proceeding

Nnamdi Kanu’s Sister-in-law barred from Court for Livestreaming Proceeding

JUST-IN: Social Activist VeryDarkMan Arrested by EFCC

EFCC releases VeryDarkMan on Bail

EFCC reacts to BBC Pidgin report on VeryDarkBlackMan’s arrest

EFCC reacts to BBC Pidgin report on VeryDarkBlackMan’s arrest

Catholic Bishops Reply Trump Over AI-Generated Pope Image

Catholic Bishops Reply Trump Over AI-Generated Pope Image

FCCPC Replies  Meta’s threat to Quit Nigeria over ₦220 Million Fine

FCCPC Replies Meta’s threat to Quit Nigeria over ₦220 Million Fine

NNPC reduces NMDPRA fee Per-Litre petrol in New Pricing Template

$3bn Refinery Fraud: N80bn found in sacked MD’s Bank Accounts

Kwara Law Students’ Association Accuses Unrecognized Actors of Sabotaging Scholarship Process”

Kwara Law Students’ Association Accuses Unrecognized Actors of Sabotaging Scholarship Process”

Court Fixes Dec 1 For The Judgment On Ogun PDP Guber Ticket Tussle [Details]

NJC Suspends Justices Iyang, Ekwo, Aliyu For 1 Year Over Misconduct, 27 Others Face Probe

  • About Us
  • Advertise with Us
  • Editorial Policy
Friday, May 9, 2025
  • Login
iDeemlawful
  • Home
  • News
  • Featured
  • Politics
  • Life Style
  • Advertise with Us
  • Opinion
  • Campus
No Result
View All Result
iDeemlawful
No Result
View All Result
No Result
View All Result
iDeemlawful
  • Home
  • News
  • Featured
  • Politics
  • Commentary
  • Editorial
  • Campus
Home GPS Gadget law Articles

CAUSATION AND CRIMINAL LIABILITY IN NIGERIA; THE POSITION OF THE LAW

by iDeemlawful
March 6, 2025
A A
CAUSATION AND CRIMINAL LIABILITY IN NIGERIA; THE POSITION OF THE LAW
FacebookTwitterWhatsapp

CAUSATION AND CRIMINAL LIABILITY IN NIGERIA; THE POSITION OF THE LAW.

                 BY M.B KUCHICHI 

Preamble:

In criminal Law, before the accused is said to be convicted, there must be a causal link between the action of the accused person and death of the deceased/victim. Where however, there is no link between the act of the accused and the death of the deceased, there can be no criminal liability on the part of the accused. Hence, ACTUS NOVUS INTERVENIN should not be inferred from the circumstances of the case.

RelatedPosts

ISLAMIC FINANCE IN THE LIGHT OF ETHICS AND PROFIT

When Wolves Wear Sheep’s Clothing by Fatimah Hamid

‘Rental Nightmares’: How house agents bleed tenants dry with fraudulent, multiple inspection fees

Healing The Trauma Spectrum: Strategies for Overcoming Inherited and Non-Inherited Trauma

To sum everything up, in his wordings, while explaining this very topic to us in the lecture hall, Professor Yahaya Abubakar Muhammad said and I quote ” Mr. A administered poison to Mr. B, while in the process of dying, Mr. C shoot s Mr.B to death. Who caused the death?! ” This is just a rhetorical question which expressly levelled the guiltiness on the part of Mr. C.

On the other hand, contributory negligence is never a defense to criminal liability. What this mean is that where the victim died as a result of his negligence to take proper medication or care or even blood transfusion, the accused still remain liable of his act. Thus for example:

In the case of R V. BLAUE (1975) Vol 3 All E.R, the accused stabbed the deceased who was subsequently taken to the hospital. At the hospital, the victim refused to take blood transfusion because it was against her faith as a Jehovah witness. The court convicted the accused for manslaughter.

On appeal, the accused contended that the refusal of the deceased to take transfusion because of her religion was unreasonable. Thus, it should be held to have broken the causal chain. The court of appeal dismissed the appeal and upheld the accused’s conviction.

The court had this to say:

” It has long been the policy of the law that those who use violence on other people must take their victim as they find them. This, in our judgement, means the whole man and not just the physical man.

It does not lie in the mouth of the assailant to say that the victim’s religious beliefs which inhibited him from accepting certain kinds of treatment were unreasonable.

The question for decision is “what caused her death?” And the answer is the stab wound. The fact that the victim refused to stop this end coming about did not break the causal connection between the act and the death.”

In R. V. HOLLAND, the court held that a treatment like stitches, or antiseptic cleansing and bandaging could likely have saved the victim, however its refusal and resultant death would not let the accused go scott free.

By the provision of S.312 of the Criminal Code, when a person causes a bodily injury to another from which death results, it is immaterial that the injury might have been avoided by proper precaution on the part of the person injured, or that his death from that injury might have been prevented by proper care or treatment. This is similar to the provisions of the Hallsbury’s Laws of England.

It should also be noted that by the provision of S.310 of the Criminal Code, a person would be deemed to have killed another if by threat, intimidation or deceit, he causes that other person to do an act or make an omission which results in his death.

In the case of R. V. NWAOKE (1939) Vol 5 WACA, the accused threatened the deceased with a charm that if he doesn’t pay up the debt that he owed the accused, he would not be able to eat or sleep and he would subsequently die. Subsequently, the deceased was depressed and he committed suicide.

The trial court convicted the accused. On appeal, the West African Court of Appeal allowed the appeal on the ground that there was no causal link between the threat of the accused and the subsequent suicide of the deceased. Thus, the accused was discharged and acquitted.

It is also important to note that, by section 314 of the Criminal Code, chain of causation is broken where the victim dies after the expiration of a year and a day.

On a final note, however, where there is contradictory evidences as to what actually causes the death of the deceased, there can be no liability on the part of the accused person. Thus, in OFORLETE vs The STATE (2000) vol 12 NWLR pt 681, the accused hit the deceased on the head with a kitchen stool. Complications didn’t arise until three months later when the head of the deceased got swollen. He was rushed to the hospital where he spent two weeks and was subsequently sent to a psychiatric hospital where he died.

There was contradictory evidence of two medical doctors that there was the possibility of a different factor causing the death of the deceased. The trial court convicted the accused. On appeal, the court of appeal upheld the decision of the trial court.

On further appeal to the Supreme Court, the court set aside the judgement of the lower court and was of the opinion that in establishing a causal link between the act of the accused and the relevant consequence as a factual question, no aspect of the enquiry should be left to assumption, speculation or conjecture.

M.B KUCHICHI
Final Year student of Law, University of Maiduguri. 14th Sept, 2022.
modubabakuchichi@gmail.com

Tags: M.B KUCHICHIopinion
Previous Post

Ex-UNIJOS VC heads Plateau APC gov campaign

Next Post

15 Steps, Actions to Claim Estates, Assets Of Dead Parents, Grandparents, Other Relatives Who Died In UK [Full List Dead Nigerians With Unclaimed Properties]

iDeemlawful

iDeemlawful

Related Posts

MY HOME TOWN (MUWO, NUPE) by MUSTAPHA SULAIMAN MAMMAN
Life Style

MY HOME TOWN (MUWO, NUPE) by MUSTAPHA SULAIMAN MAMMAN

When Wolves Wear Sheep’s Clothing by Fatimah Hamid
Commentary

When Wolves Wear Sheep’s Clothing by Fatimah Hamid

Essentiality or Otherwise of the Defendant’s Presence in a Criminal Litigation: A Constitutional Right of Fair Hearing —Composed By Adeshina Umarfaruq Olaitan
law Articles

Essentiality or Otherwise of the Defendant’s Presence in a Criminal Litigation: A Constitutional Right of Fair Hearing —Composed By Adeshina Umarfaruq Olaitan

‘Rental Nightmares’: How house agents bleed tenants dry with fraudulent, multiple inspection fees
Commentary

‘Rental Nightmares’: How house agents bleed tenants dry with fraudulent, multiple inspection fees

THE DOCTRINE OF SEPARABILITY IN ARBITRATION
Commentary

THE DOCTRINE OF SEPARABILITY IN ARBITRATION

Commentary

Sexually transmitted Diseases and the Law: Can victims in Nigeria seek Justice? by Lanase Usman

Illustration of mediator and arbitrator
Commentary

MEDIATOR ACTING AS ARBITRATOR: UNDERSTANDING SECTION 79 OF THE ARBITRATION AND MEDIATION ACT, 2023

Lagos govt mandates permits for amplified sound in nightclubs, worship centres
law Articles

Lagos govt mandates permits for amplified sound in nightclubs, worship centres

Shariah law —– a foreign law in a foreign land
Commentary

Shariah law —– a foreign law in a foreign land

Healing The Trauma Spectrum: Strategies for Overcoming Inherited and Non-Inherited Trauma
Opinion

Healing The Trauma Spectrum: Strategies for Overcoming Inherited and Non-Inherited Trauma

Load More

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

iDeemlawful

Copyright © 2019–2025 Deemlawful Media

  • About Us
  • Advertise with Us
  • Editorial Policy

Connect With Us

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • News
  • Featured
  • Politics
  • Life Style
  • Advertise with Us
  • Opinion
  • Campus

Copyright © 2019–2025 Deemlawful Media

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In